Topper Copies

मूल संरचना सिद्धांत केवल एक न्यायिक नवाचार नहीं है, बल्कि एक राजनीतिक हस्तक्षेप भी है। / The Basic Structure doctrine is not merely a judicial innovation, but also a political intervention.

Animesh Jain, AIR 63, 2025

Indian democracy is based on idea of Constitutionalism. This means a form of government limited by the Constitution. This is reflected in the Basic structure doctrine given by S.C in Kesavananda Bharati case.

B.S.D is a judicial innovation to safeguard basic tenets of constitution without constraining Parliament's power to amend the constitution to realise socio-economic objectives. Thus, rejecting Golaknath verdict that fundamental rights are unalterable, S.C held that it can be amended for realising DPSP, without harming B.S.D.

With time, element like federalism, secularism, free & fair election, welfare state etc have been interpreted under R.S.D. This gives it a political color.

It aims at checking authoritarianism. For example, S.C striked down 39th amendment Act in Indira Gandhi v/s Raj Narain case.

Scholars like Zia Mody held that without RSD India would have Constitution without constitutionalism. However it has been criticised as judicial activism and violating of principle of parliament sovereignty by Vice President Jagdeep Dhankar.

Nonetheless, R.S.D remains a North star in guiding the judiciary in role of Dr Chandrachud ensuring protection of Indian democracy