Topper Copies

Eurocentric constructs of modern state do not serve purpose of the third world in nation building. Discuss in light of recent takeovers of Afghanistan by Taliban. (15 M)

Swathika R P

Afghanistan has been considered as "graveyard of empires", due to the failure of erstwhile British empire, USSR and recently USA to influence its nation building.

While classical tradition of comparative politics was dominated by legal-institutional approach, the same cannot be applied to developing countries.

This is because eurocentric constructs like homogeneous society, society based on principle of liberty, equality, rights, secularism are not of relevance in third world countries.

Instead, in third world countries, we see difference between text and context, formalism where there is difference between theory and practice.

F. W. Riggs defines Third world as prismatic societies where societies have mix of modernity and tradition.

In Afghanistan, while we see modern institutions like Parliament, foreign services, however they continue to be under Shariat law.

Similarly, Samuel P Huntington has given the concept of political decay to explain the decline or exceptionalism of democracy in third world countries.

This has led to development of modern approaches like political sociology and political economy which play a greater role in third world countries.

Even Machiavelli had suggested "republic wherever possible, but iron law wherever necessary".

Thus the American scholar construct of Arab exceptionalism can be seen as a guide to West's approach towards nation building of third world countries.