Topper Copies

Discuss India's concerns about Belt and Road Initiative

Priyasha Verma, AIR 324, 2025

China's Belt and Road Initiative is a mix of Mahan's Sea Power approach and Mackinder's Land Power approach. It has components like Land Silk Road, Maritime Silk Route and a proposed Polar Silk Route in the Arctic.

India's concerns about BRI 1. BRI's component of China-Pakistan Economic Corridor passes through Aksai Chin area which violates India's territorial sovereignty. 2. Chinese projects under BRI in Asia are seen as a String of Pearls and leading to Strategic Encirclement of India. eg. port in Djibouti, Gwadar port, Hambantota port, Kyaukphyu Port in Myanmar. 3. China uses its debt trap diplomacy and huge money power to gain economic projects in India's neighbours in need, unlike India which does not have such deep pockets. eg. Colombo Port City Development in Sri Lanka or huge infrastructure in Africa. 4. China by BRI engages in Complex Interdependence with countries it does not have excellent relations with. eg. 16+1 Framework in Europe. 5. BRI increases dominance of China in the region and gives it military advantage wherever it constructs infrastructure. Eg. near Chabahar Port in Iran.

India, recently became the only SCO member not to endorse China's BRI. According to S Jaishankar, India must remain away from China's charm offensives and continue to oppose BRI as it doesn't offer a single good thing to India.