Topper Copies

The changing conception of security in international relations, from the realist, state-centric view to human and non-traditional security.

Swathika R P

Security is considered the core national interest of nations according to the realist perspective.

This is based on the premise that state & relations in international system, based on anarchy is the struggle for power.

Increase in powers by one state is perceived as a source of threat to other state leading to security dilemma.

Changing concepts of security in international relations are as follows.

While realists give importance to security of state, this has led to debate on concept of security like:

1. Security of what? 2. Security of whom? 3. Security against what? 4. Security using what means?

As opposed to State's security, feminism, liberalism and Post modernism schools give importance to human security.

This has led to shift from westphalian idea of non-interference in domestic affairs to the concept of Responsibility to protect (R2P) under United Nations.

Feminist critique of realism, especially in the context of security can be seen from Ann J Tickner's reformulation of six principles of Morgenthau.

According to which, ethics cannot be separated from politics and states have to find common moral interests in guiding the relation.

Moreover, feminist also stress on the role of norms, values in guiding the relations.

For example: Hilary Clinton had stressed on the subject of human and women safety in US foreign policy. Even NGOs have put feminist perspective in the centre while funding the projects in developing countries.

Approach towards security in 21st century

While security in traditional sense was seen as a threat to life by one state against another, 21st century circumstances require a change in approach.

According to Ramachandra Guha and Sunita Narain, environmental security is closely linked to human security.

IPCC sixth assessment report mention "tipping point" of climate if global commitments on climate change are not strengthened. This will lead to "new dynamic" and "climate refugees" creating security concern.

Growing role of transnational actors and asymmetric powers has also necessitated the expanding horizon of security framework. For example, FATF maintains grey list and black list to deter terrorist financing.

Recent US supreme court judgement on abortion rights has also reinvigorated debate on human security.

Thus as Thomas Hobbes said security of life is the most important right, inalienable for all.