Topper Copies

Do you agree with notion that Marxist perspective of I.R suffers from economic reductionism? Give reasons.

Swathika R P

Marxist school of international relations is infact considered as Marxist school of international political economy.

This is because of Marx's base and superstructure model, in which politics is only the super structure.

1. While Marx has largely focussed only on domestic sphere, but even he has acknowledged the expansionary nature of capitalism -> "search for profits has made capitalists settle everywhere and nestle everywhere" 2. Lenin's theory of imperialism marks the beginning of Instrumentalist school of Marxist perspective 3. Post colonial scholar like A.G Frank and Samir Amin has described the nature of relations between core and periphery as "unequal exchange", uneven development, development & under development 4. Immanuel Wallerstein's World system theory has argued against Political modernization of Samuel P Huntington based on economic development 5. Also, Wallerstein based his argument on core, periphery and semi periphery spatial dimension and how economic exploitation happens. He even calls for "national autonomous development"

Based on the above reasons it can be concluded that Marxist perspective is "monocausal" and suffers from economic reductionism.

This is even acknowledged by Neo Marxist scholar Robert Cox who has aimed to redefine it.

Robert Cox aim to rectify it by introducing the role of culture and ideological factors that has helped capitalism become world system.

USA's soft powers and ability to convince the world of benefit of liberal international economic order (LIEO) is used as an example.

Thus, neo marxist and Critical school has aimed to redefine marxist approach and prevent it from becoming economic reductionism.