"What matters is power and not appeal to Justice, even Good does not help, only self-help works" - Thucydides. Comment.
Swathika R P
Above statement of Thucydides, based on analysis of Peloponnesian war marks the beginning of Realist school of International relations.
Realist tradition is centred around the importance of Power in International relations which have been acknowledged by ancient philosophers as follows.
- Kautilya -> relations between states is Jungle, in which Vijigshu must always acquire dominance - Machiavelli -> there is a clear separation of ethics and politics in 'Realpolitik' - Thomas Hobbes -> State of nature is when "might is right", thus life is nasty, poor, brutish and short
Modern realist school consists of two branches:
Classical realist like Hans Morgenthau in his book "Politics among Nations" gives 5 assumptions of International relations:
1. International politics is Anarchic 2. Security is the highest concern 3. Survival is the primary national interest 4. Since anarchic, thus no world government. Self help is the only way for sovereign states 5. Self help is about increasing power either internal balancing or external balancing leading to "balance of power"
Morgenthau called his work scientific as it was based on 6 principles of:
1. Human nature: animus dominandi 2. National interest: survival 3. Dynamics of national interest: keep changing with world order 4. Role of ethics: autonomous 5. Role of ideology: idea should not be brought into relation 6. Power politics
However it was criticized by liberals like Stanley Hoffman as suffering from "Power monism".
Neo realism
While Kenneth Waltz and Mearsheimer both give priority to structure of international system over human nature. Kenneth Waltz is defensive realist. According to him, "unended search for power" leads to destruction and thus states should be only security maximizer.
However Mearsheimer is an offensive realist who believes in power maximization.
Neo classical realist like Fareed Zakaria and Gideon Rose believes in the role of both human nature and structure which causes international relations as "struggle for power".
However, pure power politics of Realists is criticised by liberals like Woodrow Wilson as leading to "unnecessary war" and "unnecessary extension of war".
Feminists like Ann J Tickner has reformulated 6 principles of Morgenthau and brings ethics and care to centrality.
Despite criticism, Realists continue to be guided by "Whatever is the ultimate end, power is always the immediate end" clause.