Topper Copies

Analyze the feminist critique of liberal theory in International Relations. What alternative feminist approaches have been proposed to address these criticisms?

Gautam Singh

Feminism refers to ideology concerned with ending the neglect of women and bringing them to the centre of policy making from peripheries.

In international relations, feminist ideology developed with Ann. J. Tickners criticism of Morgenthau's basis principles of foreign policy. Tickner provides for feminist human nature, human security instead of territorial security, Cooperation (rather than anarchy), and confluence of ethics and politics.

Criticising the liberal theory, like the marxist, feminist argue that liberals are only concerned with profits of capitalist class and stay away from addressing the real concern of human security.

Hillary Clinton while criticising US approach for neglecting women issue in Afghanistan policy held that "human rights are actually women rights."

Likes of Clinton and Cynthia Enloe criticise the liberals for painting wrong perspective in themes like complex interdependence, functionalism and democratic peace, as women rights are not echoed even in democracies.

In her work, Banana, Beaches and Bases, Enloe regrets the absence of women from policy making leading to war crimes against women (rapes during Gaza crisis) and exploitation of children and women during Ukraine crisis. Emphasizing need of female voice she says- Personal is International.

Margot Wallenstony, the Swedish foreign minister has suggested 3R approach [Representation, Rights and resources] for women on policy making front. It will not only secure women's right, but also make world peaceful.

Ningfama Rao, while praising Vijaylakshmi Pandit's tenure at UN, emphasized for seprate women policies in the foreign policy of UN.

Due to these voices, steps have been taken as Sweden declared seprate foreign policy on women; UN resolution 1325 - held presence of women perspective on war, peace related issues. further, both MOGs and SOGs have special provisions for women.

- The need of the hour is to shift the masculinist discipline of IR towards feminist discourse as "we the people must include she the people"