Critically examine the relevance of the theory of Nuclear Deterrence in preventing war in the international system.
Gautam Singh
Deterrence word emerged from latin word de-ter (to frighten), that means it is a psychological concept to frighten the enemy to avoid war.
It emerged with Game theorists like Thomas Schelling during cold-war, realists giving it credit for keeping the cold war cold (Waltz).
However, post-cold war there has been question mark on its relevance due to development of Security community in trans-atlantic, complex-interdependence and threat coming from non-state actor. Further, social-constructivists like Nina Tannenwald consider it irrelevant as it is not to be used due to nuclear taboo.
The question mark on relevance is also valid as deterrence could not stop theater wars (conventional) during cold war. Even today nuclear powers like India-China fight over Doklam, Kargil war between nuclear powers, and failure to stop Ukraine war.
However, continuous reliance and growing arsenal of nuclear weapons (in France, UK), Nuclear posture review of USA and recent Japanese effort of deterrence against Korea and China show that N. deterrence is an evergreen game.
Hence, as Bernard Brodie held as long states remain rational and security remain central - N. deterrence remains relevant.