Topper Copies

"Globalization has rendered the nation-state obsolete." Do you agree or disagree?

Gautam Singh

Thomas Friedman in his book "The Lexus and olive trees" defines globalisation as inoxrable interconnectedness of individuals, nations, markets and technology.

The process started in 15th c with european adventurism and with growth of ICTs, inter-state trade, birth of WTO at end of 20th c, it is growing farther, faster, deeper and cheaper.

Hence, scholars of globalist perspective (liberals), contend that Globalisation has led nation-state obsolete.

Kenichi Ohmae in (book- Borderless world) gave concept of global citizen, which demands global goods and cannot be controlled by respective state. Hence, post-modern sovereignty has emerged with complex-interdependence.

Similarly, Manfred Machluhan, explaining role of internet, ICT, gives concept of global village, where communication and transportation is facilitating movement of people and ideas.

Susan strange (book - Casino capitalism) says global polity has emerged, where trans-national movements (#metoo, blacklivesmatter, Mhasa Amini), NGOs (Amnesty international) are outside of state control.

Today, MNCs control 40% of global output, 80% global trade. $15 billion is traded daily on stock exchanges and events like Asian fin. crisis (1997) and Global crisis of 2008 can shake whole world - outside capability of nation-state.

Realist scholars however, counter this view. Robert Gilpin argues that globalisation is controlled by states as trade is the oldest nexus among states. They argue that shells of sovereignty are still intact as reflected in approaches like America first, Chinese dream and Atmanirbhar Bharat.

Ashutosh Varshney in [crisis of globalisation] indicates how rise of ultra-right in France, Italy, Germany leading to closing borders, anti-immigration policies is threat to globalisation itself.

Similarly, Samir Saran talks about gated globalisation where state allow openness only as per their national interest (eg. China - open economy but not twitter, fb etc).

Finally, Md. Ayub says- after covid crisis, state is dead, has converted into long-live nation-state.

Hence, yes globalisation has transformed nation state sovereignty but no way made it obsolete. In fact, states today use sovereignty to bargain with agents of globalisation itself (UN, WTO etc)

Hence, as Kofi Annan held- Globalisation and sovereignty are not zero-sum game. Both should cooperate for greater good.