Topper Copies

Discuss the concept of soft power given by Joseph Nye. What are the structural and characteristic changes in the contemporary world order that have increased its relevance.

Gautam Singh

Max Weber defines Power as the ability to force one's will on someone else's behaviour.

International politics is dominated by realist school, called power-monist. Morgenthau held that- "whatever may be the ultimate end, power is always the immediate end."

On contrary to realist view of hard power, Joseph Nye gave concept of soft power based on norms, values and shared goodwill.

Nye argued that U.S. could maintain its hegemony even after WW II due to soft power of liberal democracy, open market and norm values like human rights, justice etc.

He held that over-emphasis on hard-power leads to over-stretching and collapse of hegemony [USSR in Afghanistan, US in Vietnam].

Although, being criticized by Marxist for interpellating capitalist ideas to est. hegemony [Robert Cox] and by Communitarians for Westoxication and destroying indigenous Culture [Michael Sandels], the contemporary changes in current world are losing its utility.

With growing inter-dependence, development of nuclear deterrence and rise of external watchdogs (NGOs, UN) etc, use of coercive power is not recommended.

Further, war is fought today on ideological front, through diplomacy, export of culture, media [Al-Jazeera etc]. That is why even developing countries like India are focusing on vaccine diplomacy, emphasis on culture etc.

As held by PM Modi, India can increase its soft power through Samriddhi, Suraksha, Samman and Samangaya.