Topper Copies

In what ways does the Neorealist emphasis on the structure of the international system alter the traditional Realist understanding of war and peace?

Gautam Singh

Realism is a school of empirical paradigm, based on westphilian world order, that explains the world order as it is (power view), rather than how it ought to be.

Although it started in east with Kautilya [Arthshastra], SunTzu and in west with Thucydides, Hobbes, Machiavelli; in modern times it emerged as criticism to utopianism of Woodrow Wilson's liberal world order during inter war period.

Traditional (classical) Realism started with Hans Morgenthau's "Politics among nations" (1948), which based it's analysis on human nature. Like Machiavelli's Animus dominendi, states in IR also are concerned with survival and hence are power-seeking. The self-help for ensuring security leads to alliance, BOP and ultimately war.

Neo-realists, however, criticized traditional view for being deterministic and hence unscientific. Kenneth Waltz in his "Theory of international politics" (1969) shifts from actor level to structure level analysis. Structure of I.R. being anarchic (without world govt.), structural differentiation and differing capabilities of nation leads to security dilemma. Hence, states have no choice to act independently for war or peace.

Hence, although the basic assumptions of anarchy, survival, self-help and power monism [Stanley Hoffman] remains the same, the analytical aspect of war and peace has been reformed.

Further, Neo-classical realists have reformed neo-realism with Fareed Zakaria and Randall Schweller including both actor and structure in their analysis.

Due to this reformist tendency of realist scholars as per understanding of time, Realism has remained as timeless wisdom, other schools being merely footnotes of realism.