Discuss the contribution of comparative methods in understanding the political systems. Also briefly mention the challenges of comparative politics in the context of globalisation.
Gautam Singh
[Hague and Harrop] in their work "Comparative government and polity" define it as- methodical sub-discipline of political science which uses systematic comparison as method of political inquiry.
It started with Aristotle's study of 148 constitutions and later developed as traditional comparative politics which provided legal-institutional comparison of developed world on basis of historical, legal and philosophical approach.
Later on modern comparative politics, as held by Greenleaf, provides a venue for study of political and societal interface (political sociology), economic impact of state policies (pol. economy) and normative suggestions to develop third world countries (political development)
However, after globalisation of world as reflected in complex-interdependence, comparative method faces challenges such as plethora of variables (history, society, economy), lack of objectivity, poor quality of info (in countries like China).
[Neera Chandhoke] argue that comparative analysis still suffers from fallacies of orientalism and have eurocentric outlook in studying the developing world. [FW Riggs]
Further, the over-broad and inter-disciplinary approach makes it difficult to decide - what to include, what to exclude.
However, despite these challenges this approach has helped in understanding of neo-colonialism- [dependency school], role of ethnicity in politics (Christophe Jaffrelot) and above all, interface of society, polity and economy [S.M. Lipset].