How is Comprehensive National Power an advanced concept?
Gautam Singh
Power is ability to force own will on others (Hobbes), which in IR is seen as most potent tool for serving survival, national interest through various means.
Likes of Morgenthau, Waltz and Mearsheimer rely on hard power where as liberals (Joseph Nye) propagate soft power (norms, values etc)
However, Comprehensive National Power as propounded by Hilary Clinton in form of Smart power is most recent and advanced concept. It is combination of both hard and soft power.
Apart from developing security capability in form of army, weaponisation etc it focuses on developing cultural image through diplomacy, media and diaspora.
Contemporary example of CNP is USA, which apart from being largest military is also global hegemon of cultural export through liberal democratic order, open market etc.
Hence, CNP is an advanced concept as it amalgamates basic tenant of all major schools - realism (hard power), Liberalism (norms, values), communism (hegemony, interpellation), post modern (power is what we make of it), and hence describes current order accurately.