Topper Copies

Q3. (a) What are the key elements of India's Nuclear doctrine? In the prevailing geopolitical environment, should India go for revision of its nuclear doctrine? (20 Marks)

Priyasha Verma, AIR 324, 2025

According to Rajesh Rajur, "India's Nuclear Doctrine is based on greater cultural beliefs than strategic implications." According to C Raja Mohan India's Nuclear Doctrine shows its nuclear abhorrence.

India adopted a Nuclear doctrine in wake of Pokhran - II test and established itself as a responsible nuclear weapon state.

Key elements of India's Nuclear Doctrine a. No First Use policy b. Credible Minimum Deterrance c. Massive Retaliation d. Nuclear control with Civilian authority e. Global Nuclear Disarmament f. Formation of Nuclear Triad

India does not believe in offensive nuclear capability but only as a retaliation. It aims to develop Second Strike Capability and respond with massive retaliation.

It makes its position clear on nuclear disarmament on global level by only Credible "Minimum" Deterrance and not full fledged arms race.

With INS Arihant, it has embarked upon the journey to create a Nuclear Triad ie having capability to launch nuclear weapons from air, land and water.

Revision of Nuclear Doctrine With rising security dilemma in South Asia and risk of Two front war with Pakistan and China, there are voices emerging to revise the nuclear doctrine. In wake of terrorist attack by Pakistan, there were voices in Indian political sphere too to change No First Use (NFU) Policy to First Use.

Bharat Karnad believes that NFU policy is applicable only to these countries which have confidence in second strike capability. He believes that it is morally wrong to put lives of people in danger in the wake of rise of nuclear terrorism.

However, Shiv Shankar Menon believes only in the deterrant value of nuclear weapons and not their use in any case. It has only to be used for ideological posturing.

Manpreet Sethi believes that First Use Policy can cause heavy burden on exchequer and contribute to security dilemma by keeping nuclear weapons on trigger.

Also, he disagrees with changing the policy of Credible minimum Deterrance as it is in line with India's traditional belief of pacifism.

He suggests DIME approach (Diplomacy, Information, Military, Economic) to deal with nations. Also conventional war capabilities must be improved along with preparing for hybrid war, space and cyber war etc. India must continue with its support on Comprehensive, Verifiable and Universal Disarmament.