Topper Copies

Keynes assumed that monetary policy is fully ineffective. How was his theory expounded by Neo keynesian approach.

Ruhani, AIR 5, 2023

Keynes assumed that monetary policy is fully ineffective because of the following reasons:

1. Liquidity trap: Keynes assumed that at low rates of interest, LM curve is horizontal as people want to hold all their wealth in the form of money at low rates of interest.

[an interest rate vs output diagram, an IS curve sloping down meeting a horizontal-then-upward-sloping LM curve at low interest rate r₀]

Thus, due to horizontal LM curve, any further increase in money supply will not increase aggregate demand and hence, output.

2. Money illusion: which means that people look only at nominal variables and not the real variables. Hence, if monetary policy reduces rate of Inflation, the investors may not be able to appreciate that their real rate of interest has increased (as real roi = nominal roi - Inflation rate) and thus, may not invest more.

Neo-Keynesian approach Combines Keynesian approach with other schools of thought like classical, Monetarist, New Classical to arrive at the idea that Monetary Policy is effective in the short run.

It also says that LM curve is upward-sloping and hence, any expansionary Monetary Policy leads to increase in output.

[a price vs output diagram, an IS curve with two LM curves, LM(M₀) and LM'(M₁), shifted, with Y₀ and Y₁ marked]

Neo-keynesians also remove the assumption of money illusion and state that economic agents form expectations about a policy change and thus, accordingly change their behaviour to minimize the impact of policy on output in the long run.

Thus, according to Neo-keynesians, expansionary monetary policy has no impact on output in the long run.

Keynes assumed that money supply is exogenous. However, Neo-Keynesians admit that money supply is actually endogenous as money supply depends on interest rate (which is the target variable for most Central Banks under the inflation targeting regime).

Thus, Neo-keynesians have made Keynesian theory more comprehensive and in line with the reality of monetary policies carried out by most Central Banks of the world.