Topper Copies

Explain the Aristotelian views of politics. To what extent do you think it has contributed to the development of modern day constitutional democracies?

Unknown

Aristotle is regarded as the father of political science as his book 'Politics' is considered to be the first exclusive book dedicated to politics.

Aristotelian views on politics are shaped by the views of his teacher Plato as both belong to Socratic tradition. However, Aristotle disagrees with Plato on several aspects.

Nature of state Like Plato, Aristotle also believes that state is natural and organic and is necessary for a man to lead be good life. He goes to the extent of calling state the highest of all associations.

Form of government Here Aristotle differs from his master. While Plato advocates a philosopher king, Aristotle calls 'polity' as the best practicable form of government.

Aristotle bases his conclusions on thorough analysis of 158 constitutions to arrive at his concept of ideal state. He agrees that philosopher king may be best but its practical form will be tyranny. He uses his principle of golden mean to arrive at Polity as best practicable form of government.

Law making Aristotle believes in deliberative democracy. He argues that laws made through deliberation represents collective wisdom. Further law is also devoid of passions. He criticizes Plato's philosopher king by highlighting that "The authority of the statesman is different from the authority of a master".

Citizenship While his conception of citizenship is very narrow, the core idea is praiseworthy. He associates citizenship with active involvement in law making and governance.

Thus, Aristotelian ideas on politics have contributed to many core concepts of modern day contemporary democracies.

The modern democracies are based on representative model where elected representatives do deliberation on laws in parliament and laws are the product of this deliberation. Some countries even direct public participation in law making process through means like initiative, referendum etc. This is a continuation of the Aristotelian idea of deliberative democracy.

Aristotle's core assertion about the duty of state is that the state has to ensure justice in society. The idea is continued even in the contemporary democracies where justice, social, economic and political, continues to be the core function of a state.

However, there are several areas in which contemporary democracies have improved upon the Aristotelian conceptions.

These include areas like citizenship where universal adult suffrage is the norm in contemporary democracies, further Aristotle's ideas about slavery have been completely rejected in the modern times. The fundamental premise of natural inequality has been rejected and most democracies are pursuing affirmative action policies to realize equality in substantive sense.

Thus while Aristotle's thoughts have contributed to the development of contemporary democracies, many of them have been thesis of Aristotelian idea, but many others have been anti-thesis of his prescriptions. Thus contemporary democracies are truly a synthesis of the dialectical movement of Aristotelian ideas.