"Plato was an enemy of open society," Popper. Comment.
Unknown
Plato is such a central figure in the western political philosophy that Whitehead rightly held that "entire western political philosophy is nothing but footnotes to Plato and Aristotle"
Plato gave different theories like philosopher king, his theory of education, Communism etc. His objective was to make Athens an ideal state.
However, in recent times several western scholars have been trying to find the roots of fascism in ancient times and in this process Karl Popper in his book 'The open society and its enemies' has traced the roots to Plato and termed him as an enemy of open society.
Popper relies on several authoritarian tendencies in Plato's works. These include his institution of Philosopher king who is considered supreme embodiment of Knowledge. Citizens are expected to have unquestioned allegiance to the king.
Further, his theory of communism of property and family are also cited by Popper to highlight his totalitarian tendencies. Plato advocates state's strict surveillance over the education system to produce desirable citizens. Further, his communism advocates that only the ablest of Athenian men should marry the ablest of Athenian women to produce racially superior children. Popper has compared all these tendencies with the totalitarian leaders and scholars of later ages.
He broadly arrives at other features of totalitarian leaders as highlights that all these are visible in Plato.
1. Holism: It means giving priority to collectivity over individuality. Plato argues that state is organic and natural and people should have unquestioned allegiance to the state. 2. Essentialism: It means that one advocates imaginary ideas to deflect attention from real issues. Plato created an utopic of an ideal state. 3. Historicism -> It refers to the political use of history. Plato gave the 'law of decay' to exhort people to follow discipline or else the ideal state will decay into Timocracy (Rule of soldier class) and further into Democracy (Rule by masses).
Karl Popper refers to these tendencies in Plato to call him an Enemy of open society.
However, it would be wrong to arrive at such definitive conclusion. Levinson rightly held that Plato differs in time and space from the totalitarian rulers of later centuries and it is too simplistic to consider him an ideological predecessor of totalitarianism.
Plato's ideas remained an utopia and never came into practice. Hence it would be unfair to blame him for totalitarianism of 19th and 20th centuries.
Some scholars argue that Popper used Plato as a tool to support his thesis which lacks substance.
Every thinker is a child of his times and extrapolating his ideas to explain the outcomes of different era comes with its own risks, and definitive conclusions are difficult to draw.