'Where there is no common power, there is no law; where no law, no injustice'. Critically analyse.
Kunal Agarwal
Hobbes was a social contract thinker in Britain. He wrote his book 'Leviathan' providing his theory of State. Hobbes used physics, psychology and geometry to arrive at a consistent theory of State.
Hobbes use Descartes' method of Resolutive-Composite to analyse human nature. According to him, Man is driven by motion of atoms. There are two motions; aversion or attraction. Man reacts to external stimuli and thus experience pleasure or pain. According to him, before the State was created, man lived in State of nature. He proved that Man is individualistic by nature and thus State of nature is a continuous struggle for power. There is no common authority or law in state of nature.
In state of nature, might is right. Every man can interpret law in their own way. This leads to a state of anarchy and chaos. In absence of a common power, the powerful man aims to maximize their power further. The life of man is a continuous search for power after power which ends only with their life. There is no justice in such a state of nature. Those with power will enforce their will.
In such a state, the life of man becomes nasty, poor & brutish. He proposed a state through social contract between all people to create a common power i.e. Leviathan. Man surrenders all their rights except right to self-preservation to Leviathan in order to attain peace.
In creation of a state, Hobbes created a absolutist sovereign authority which enforces law of state. Hobbes is a believer of positive law and rejects other laws. For him, "law is the command of the sovereign". Those who do not obey law can be punished. Such a State accordingly to him, has common law for all & thus justice is ensured by Leviathan.
Macpherson has criticised Hobbes for starting as an individualist and ending as an absolutist. Hobbes took a pessimistic view of human nature. He has preffered sovereignty over liberty due to his experiences in Britain. It is to be noted that absolute authority can lead to violation of human rights. However, Common law is a necessity to ensure peaceful functioning of state & justice.