Topper Copies

"Machiavelli was the child of Renaissance and the father of realism". Critically analyse.

Kunal Agarwal

Machiavelli is called father of realism and a child of renaissance. He was born in Italy when the politics was influenced by religion & ethics. There was corruption in Church as well as among common people.

He is called greatest patriot who was focused on building a strong and great Italy. The politics was at that time (medieval times) mixed with religion.

Renaissance was just beginning. He was a thinker who reflected principles of renaissance i.e. rationalism, humanism in his thoughts.

Machiavelli in his books 'Prince' & 'Discourses' puts human at the centre. His theory of statecraft derives heavily from his study of human nature. He studies history as he believed that a prince should be master in real world than in the world of ideas. Machiavelli is a realist Thinker who has spoken truth about politics.

He has given a 'Iron hand' prince monarch whose aim is to attain power, keep it & maximize it. His thinking im influenced by real world politics than ideas as was the case with Plato. In building a strong nation-state in Italy, Machiavelli gave his views on role of religion, ethics etc. He is known to give a secular theory of state.

During his time, Italy was divided into 5 provinces. Church was corrupt and he believed that Italy remained weak because of interference by church. He argued that Prince's options should not be limited by religion. Separation of State and religion should be ensured. Similarly, he provided 'dual morality'.

Prince's action should not be judged by morality of common man. He ought to sacrifice morals (means) for ends to preserve his people & country. Thus, Machiavelli provided a strong Monarch who can rule with iron hand in a real world of politics.

Sabine has criticised Machiavelli for being narrowly dated and narrowly located. However, it is to be noted that similar real-politik ideas have been propounded by Kautilya. His ideas have also been criticized for being too negative & one sided in analysing human nature.

It can certainly be said to his credit that he brought ideas of renaissance in political thought and promoted real world politics.