Topper Copies

"Each man is an end in itself. No one ought to treat the other as a means to an end" -Immanuel Kant. Critically analyse with respect to Aristotle's Theory of Slavery.

Kunal Agarwal

Aristotle was an advocate of slavery. He had a utilitarian approach to slavery. Like Plato, Aristotle believed in natural capabilities of man. He argued that some are born masters and some are born slaves.

Aristotle gave his theory of slavery for slaves by nature and not for slaves by law. He provided a utilitarian justification for advocating slavery. He argued that master is born with reason and courage which slaves do not possess. It is for the benefit of slaves to be under a master. They learn virtue. Slaves need master's guidance. In addition, masters also benefit- because they get time to participate in affairs of the State. through this functional specialization, the State benefits from institution of slavery.

Aristotle has treated slaves as a means to an end.

Kant has criticized Aristotle arguing that human dignity is a categorical imperative and no one should be treated as means. Every man is an end in itself. Aristotle was a 'status quoist' who preferred stability and thus continued the institution of slavery.

However, it is to be noted that in modern world of democracy, human dignity is central. Human is at the centre of all development. The arguments of natural differentiation and utility have been used to propagate theories of white men's burden' and for the benefit of civilization. However, as history stands as evidence, this led to exploitation & subjugation of section of population.

Human rights are violated through such slavery. It has been seen time and again in different geographies that this has created inequalities.

Each man is an end in itself. They should be kept at centre as advocated in modern world of democracies, human rights.