"Those states are best governed where rulers are reluctant to govern rather than eager to govern"- Plato. Critically analyse.
Kunal Agarwal
Plato is an idealist thinker who want to establish an ideal state in Athens where peace and harmony will prevail. Plato proposed his idea of an ideal state based on his theory of souls. According to him, persons in whom reason prevails are the ones fit for rule. His philosophy argued that either philosophers should be rulers or rulers should learn philosophy.
He argued that a philosopher king is driven by reason and not passion for money and power. Thus, a philosopher king is reluctant to govern. They are more interested in attaining true knowledge than governing. They make a sacrifice for the sake of state to govern.
On the other hand, a king who is eager to govern will have passion for power and mony. Power and mony were seen to source of corruption leading to poor governance of States. Kings & Rulers who are eager to govern are driven by self-interest rather than interest of all. In them, apetite & courage dominates reason and thus, they can not understand truth leading to poor governance of states.
Rulers who are reluctant to govern, according to Plato, are knowledgeable and knows how to govern. They are dominated by reason and thus, can understand God's idea of justice, implement the same in the ideal state proposed by Plato.
However, Plato's ideas of philosopher king has been criticized by his own disciple Aristotle. A ruler who is reluctant to govern would not care about governance. Aristotle argued that power and money are also source of motivation and thus should not be neglected.
In modern world also, Plato's ideas have relevance. Power corrupts & absolute power corrupts absolutely. Those who love power have been seen to hold power in their self-interest. Democracy and Rule of law came into existence for good governance of State in modern times.