Write a short note on fact-value dichotomy in Political Science.
Kunal Agarwal
Political science is the oldest and most vibrant disciplines. It has been called as master science. Thinkers like Aristotle (father of political science), Hobbes, Plato and modern thinkers like John Rawls has continuously evolved the discipline.
There has been continuous dichotomy of fact & value in the field. Aristotle had studied 158 constitutions to provide his own theory of best practicable state. The science was supposed to be based on facts, empirical studies, basing theories in data to come up analysis. Such fact based studies have been done in the field of politics.
However, ancient thinkers like Aristotle, Plato etc believed in the value of political science. Normative studies in the discipline helped provide betterment of state & society without such value based studies, concepts of sovereignty, secularism, democracy would not have emerged.
However, these studies were claimed to be 'arm chair theories' and thus behavouralism & system theory were emphasised upon by thinkers including David Easton. It focused on value-neutrality & scientific study.
However, soon it was realised that sitting in 'ivory tower' building theories is leading to decline of discipline. Thus, Post-behavouralism focused on scientific & empirical studies to improve system. The value based theories based studies of facts & data are accepted which to rise of political science as a major discipline once again.