Topper Copies

Mill was a champion of democracy. Yet fail to bring the idea of democracy to its logical conclusion. Discuss.

Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025

John Stuart Mill is considered as the 'Champion of liberty'. Although he is an inconsistent thinker, yet his ideas are still relevant in the contemporary time.

Mill says that 'Democracy is the best form of government'. Although he wants Direct democracy, yet he agrees that current societal conditions make it imperative to establish 'Representative democracy'. However, Mill as a 'Champion of democracy' doesn't agree on bringing democracy everywhere.

He says that 'Barbarians are better off with benevolent despotism'. In his views, India & China might be great societies before yet today they are not ready for democracy. Democracy for Mill is a gift, for which people have fought for centuries. Thus it would not be proper to introduce it everywhere.

C.L. Wayper criticizes Mill as a 'reluctant democrat'. In the context of India, Gandhi and Nehru can be considered as 'passionate democrats' as they wish to take democracy to everyone.

Mill further brings in Aristocratic element like plural voting, strengthening the house of lords, he is also not in favour of granting women & poor the right to vote. Yet he still strongly advocates that women should get the right to vote.

Thus, it would be fair to say that mill was a champion of democracy, yet he fails to bring the idea of democracy to its logical conclusion.