Only those invasions of liberty are justified, which create opportunities of further liberty (Mill). Comment.
Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025
John Stuart Mill is known as the 'Champion of liberty' as he ensured liberalism doesn't become crude capitalism. He has broadened the idea of liberty and thus, it is said that 'If there is anyone who is liberal, it is mill'.
Mill says liberty is necessary condition for development of individual. It is also necessary for the state. In this context, he says, 'No state becomes great by dwarfing its own people'. Thus, a state should grant liberty to its citizens for their development.
However, he brings in 'harm principle' as a means to justify invasion of liberty. He divides human action into self-regarding & others regarding action. Man should have Complete liberty in self-regarding actions. In others regarding action, state should interfere it if cause harm to someone.
Mill's division of human action has been criticized as they are subjective. Any action can be categorized as self-regarding or others regarding. Mill further brings in inconsistencies to his thought by giving the example of a man crossing a bridge that is about to fall. mill says, state should interfere and protect the man as his 'real will' would not be of dying.
Thus, mill brings in the meta-physical concept of 'real will' which further shows his inconsistencies. Ernst Barker calls mill as 'prophet of empty liberty'. mill wants absolute liberty on one hand & yet he leaves ample scope for state's intervention.