Identify and explain the core assumptions of idealism as an approach to International Relations. Evaluate the relevance of institutional liberalism in peace building and global cooperation. With suitable example.
Harshita Goyal, AIR 2, 2024
Idealism as an approach in the field of international politics was first promoted by Woodrow Wilson in his Fourteen Points speech.
It rests on certain assumptions about the state of International politics. Idealism assumes the state of international politics as that of anarchy. There is a rise in security dilemma between international actors which gives rise to the inevitable struggle for power in order to survive. Due to the security dilemma, states opt for self help & focus on developing their own military capabilities.
As per the Idealist scholars, international relations are based on conflict as well as cooperation, however idealism have greater focus on the role of cooperation.
Institutional liberalism as an idealist approach was propounded by Woodrow Wilson. It highlights the role of international institutions like United Nations, World Trade Organization in promoting cooperation in the state of anarchy.
As per Wilson, these institutions convert the 'jungle of anarchy into a zoo'.
In contemporary times, UN has been successful so far in preventing a third World War, through its peacekeeping operations & settlement of disputes through dialogue & diplomacy.
Institutions like UNFCCC have been able to create global cooperation on issues of climate change. Similarly, WTO has been preserving the liberal international trade through consensus.
However, this approach is criticized by classical realists & neo-realists like Kenneth Waltz & Mearsheimer for ignoring the shortcomings of these Institutions. Eg These institutions could not prevent Russia-Ukraine War or Israel-Palestine conflict.
However, despite its limitations, this approach has been significant in the overall functioning of the present multi-Polar world order.