...lineage? (the printed question, on the liberal lineage of pluralist theory of the state, is only partly legible on the page)
Minal Negi, AIR 66, 2025
Pluralist theory of state identifies various other institutions apart from state from where power flows in public sphere.
According to pluralists, masses do not directly exercise power but do it through pressure groups and lobbying. Masses with direct power is a myth.
The ideas of pluralist State seem to flow from liberal lineage. Scholars like Robert Dahl and Charles Lindblom are liberals who consider USA as a polyarchy instead of democracy. Apart from state, capitalist, media, church exercise their own share of power over public sphere.
However, Laski often considered as a modern liberal with a socialist bent also vouches for a pluralist state. According to him though state is keystone of political architecture, but other institutions and their influence show federal authority.
MacIver an extreme pluralist in his book "Political Pluralism" considers state as neither superior nor foremost institute wielding power. According to him state is just one of many institutions with authority to control individuals.
On the extreme opposite end of liberalism, Guild socialists like GDH Cole advocate for a functional parliament. Moreover, labour unions shall have complete independence from political parties.
Even Marxists like Gramsci uphold relative autonomy of other structures like culture, religion and schools.
Hence, it can be observed that though functionalist theory is liberal in spirit, it draws cues from other schools of thought. It has some socialist elements with emphasis on cultural institutions and other influential intellectuals.
Even in contemporary communist regimes like Russia and China, pluralism manifests in the form of network of elites (James Burnham). Bureaucrats, Military and capitalists hold power by interconnecting each others' spheres of influence.