Plato's distrust of the common people and his argument that they are unfit to rule (the printed question for this part is not legible on the page).
Minal Negi, AIR 66, 2025
Plato, the father of political philosophy gives his scheme of ideal state in his celebrated work "Republic". Concerning justice.
Ancient Greece and the disorder due to Pelopponnesian war where Athens lost at the hands of Sparta, hemlock to Socrates and Corruption in ruling class were some of the influences on Plato's monistic theory of state.
According to Plato, the anarchy, corruption and disorder can be brought to an end only with rule of reason. In his words, until philosophers become rulers or rulers learn philosophy, there is no end to human life.
Moreover, his conception of disorder in ancient greece was due to rule of ignorant masses. This developed his aversion towards democracy and led to his theory of philosopher king.
Consequently, he gave his theory of justice where a strictly hierarchical society with gold class ruling over the soldier class and producer class. This is a result of a system of filteration through his scheme of education creating a meritocratic society.
Moreover, he perceived human nature driven by reason, courage as well as passion. In common masses, passion tends to dominate reason, hence they cannot be given authority to rule over others.
Furthermore, common individuals are driven by love for property and family, both of which have a corrupting influence. His philosopher king being an epitome of sacrifice and knowledge does not possess either of them.
His view of democracy is that of anarchy, mobocracy and Plebeianisation as common individuals live in the world of phenomena with no knowledge of ideas in a transcendental universe.
Such sensory observations leave them ignorant of true, immutable and perfect knowledge making them unfit to rule. On the other hand, men of reason prefer stability over power and disorder.
However, scholars like Sabine criticise Plato for making an strict hierarchy with no scope of social mobility or legal backing. Nettleship criticises him for making an ideal state on the foundation of a lie that is myth of metals.
Modern human right scholars trace the seeds of totalitarianism in Plato's monism. Even Popper calls Plato as an enemy of open society, condemning him of historicism, wholesale social Engineering, holism and essentialism.
However, as Levenson in his work "In defence of Plato" rightly says, Plato's work shall be seen with historical content and evolution of his ideas over time.