Topper Copies

Equality and freedom have been considered as conflicting values but the idea of freedom has clear egalitarian implications. Critically examine

Minal Negi, AIR 66, 2025

Natural historical disadvantages and principle of redress make equality and freedom seem antithetical to each other. However, each of them inherently re-inforce one another.

Negative liberals like Locke and Hayek oppose the idea of coexistence of equality and liberty. The idea of social justice through enforced equality is called a mirage by Hayek.

Nozick in his book "Anarchy state and Utopia" calls differences in talents, skills and possessions as natural. Removal of the same would be coercion. Hence inequality in the name of justice is nothing but reverse discrimination.

Conversely, positive liberals like TH Green advocate for active state interference for just resource distribution. In his words, state is to "hinder the hindrances". Any hitherto historically disadvantaged societies deserve state intervention.

Dworkin, calls equality as a sovereign virtue. According to him no other value has been under threat due to liberty as equality. Just initial distribution through a fictional auction with state compensating for brute luck is justice in his political scheme.

Even in today's circumstances reservations generating more heat than light (RC Guha) highlight the contradictions between equality and liberty.

State's affirmative actions and ever-expanding nature of such schemes bring the debate of race to the bottom instead of seeing it as a liberating force.

For instance, Mandal case in India and domino demands of reservations thereafter show that liberty does not come inherently with equity and fair distribution.

However, scholars like Isaiah Berlin show complementary instead of competing nature of both values. According to him equality is not a hindrance, rather a pre-condition for liberty. Without equal footing, no individual can enjoy liberty to its fullest.

Welfare states like India trying to balance the liberal values of Right to life, work, education and non discrimination with redressal for historical disadvantages.

To balance both equally foundational values, Amartya Sen's capability approach is a guiding light. Every individual shall be able to realise functionality of a resource so that the initial distribution (Dworkin) is fairer.

Elizabeth Anderson's democratic equality through individual redressal rather than group based compensation can make inequality seem just. 50% ceiling in Mandal case shows harmonious construction of equality and liberty by Indian supreme court.