How valid is the argument that the development of advanced industrial countries is driven more by industrialization and modernization than by ideological commitments?
Damanpreet Arora, AIR 103, 2024
Advanced Industrial Countries
modernization and Industrialization
Why has been a matter of debate as some theorist like Neo Marxist and Gramscian scholars like Robert Cox believed that Ideological power play a big role behind the Economic power, military power of USA [propagated the idea of free trade to dominate].
However -> Robert Gilpin (Instrumental marxist) in his '[?] for Skeptical Age' held that Industrialization through capitalist class is the reason for the modernization of Advanced capitalist countries.
Although neo-Poulantzas Relative Autonomous theory believes that the ideological as material is balanced, but the Structuralism of Habermas argues that due to capitalism in Economies and socialism in Politics, Advanced Industrial Societies are bound to suffer from Legitimation crisis.
this is also true because the Ideological commitments have played a role in establishing Hegemony (Gramsci) through the Intellectual class within Integral state [civil Society + State] played a role for attaining stability Eg Glorious Revolution 1688 in Britain helped it in the process of Industrial Revolution on one hand and successful conquest of other Colonial returns from India due to the Political stability.
But Industrialization, modernization has also helped in further establishing Economic Hegemony through the concept of Dependency theory of Frank where it is not only developed because of underdevelopment of periphery, but also by exploitation of working class (Karl Marx's theory of Surplus Value).
Hence, both have played a role in the development of advanced Industrial Society as nothing has remained in the water tight container.