"Globalization has rendered the nation-state obsolete." Do you agree or disagree?
Damanpreet Arora, AIR 103, 2024
While thomas Friedman Calling the world as flat is similar toward his a Global Village [Marshall McLuhan], Borderless world [Kenichi Ohmae], At the same it questions the Monistic theory of sovereignty of thomas Hobbes where state is Supreme and Nation State was the highest of all association.
Whether Globalization has made nation state obsolete is a matter of debate because Defenders like Bob Jessop, Kenichi Ohmae believe that sovereignty of the state has not been compromised Eg Protectionist policies of countries, where Dr S. Jaishankar talks about Trusted Partners and Trusted Terrorism as a form of friendshoring in his book "Why Bharat Matters".
Thomas, [?] argue that Globalization has taken a hit on the idea of nation state (Eg) Noam Chomsky in his book 'Profit over People' calls it as harming the sovereignty, where capitalists buying and selling sovereignty in markets, similarly Robert Gilpin and Immanuel Wallerstein [Marxist] through Dependency theory have called the sovereignty of peripheries [3rd world] countries being compromised.
At the same time transformationist like David Held believe that it has been a Zero sum Game, where somewhere state is winning and somewhere Globalization is front runner. He also pointed out the Democratic deficits' and called for Cosmopolitan Idea of Globalization based on a Similar model of EU. Russia's President Vladimir Putin also recently proposed the idea of BRICS parliament.
However, from a rational perspective it is looking like Humanitarian-model of Globalization as propounded by PM Narendra Modi has taken a back seat because of the 'problem without passports' (Kofi Annan) where Terrorism, organised crime have been on the rise because of the current model of Globalization.
State Sovereignty is not just compromised by State Actors, but also by Non traditional threats like Terrorist 20 year old boy attempted assassination attempt on presidential candidate Donald Trump.
Additionally, there is a more need of multilaterals like QUAD, supply chain Resilience Initiative as is challenging the concept of State sovereignty in Nation-State -> thus Balance of Power through counter coalitions (asymmetric alliance) is what is required.
Thus, liberal Institutionalism of woodrow wilson and Joseph Nye believes in dialogue through mechanisms like UN, WTO as a forum to resolve issues otherwise the only place available would be in the battlefield (liberal Institutions can convert Zero into Zoo) so, Nation State as such is not compromised unless a Pro Active systematic Approach is followed