Topper Copies

In what ways does the Neorealist emphasis on the structure of the international system alter the traditional Realist understanding of war and peace?

Damanpreet Arora, AIR 103, 2024

Neorealist lays stress on structural understanding of International relations through 'Structural Analysis'.

Kenneth Waltz (known as Defensive Neo Realist) in his book "theory of International Power Politics" called states as 'Security Maximiser' where Balance of Power helps in prevention of conflict and is in favour of Nuclear Deterrence for preventing wars but also continues to say that Power is a means in International Politics, and not an end itself.

This is in contrast to traditional and classical realism propounded by Morgenthau in his book 'Politics among Nations' in which he gave 8 principles of International Politics based on the notion of Human Nature, and considering National Interest as Supreme, which is unguided by the Notions of ethics.

However, he goes on to say that Institutions of peace carry no meaning and war is a continuous feature in International arena, similar to Kautilya Notion that International Politics is a Jungle where Strength of the lion prevails.

It is for this reason, Morgenthau is called as the father of Realism in International Politics as held that International Politics is nothing but a struggle between Morgenthau and its critique.

while Kenneth Waltz and Stanley Hoffmann criticized for basing history of war and peace based on Human Nature, Mearsheimer (Post cold war realist, offensive realist) in his book Tragedy of Great Power Politics carried forward Morgenthau's Power-Maximizing approach and laid stress on Blood letting, Buck-Passing as opposed to Balance of Power of Defensive Neo Realism.

However, later Neo Classical Realism by Farid Zakaria and Randal Schweller aim to achieve a balance between Actor level [traditional realist] and Structural level [neo Realist] analysed similarly Social Constructivism by Alexander Wendt held that 'Anarchy is what state makes of it' and called for 'Communication' to resolve war and establish peace.