Discuss the contribution of comparative methods in understanding the political systems. Also briefly mention the challenges of comparative politics in the context of globalisation.
Damanpreet Arora, AIR 103, 2024
Aristotle, called as the father of Comparative Politics studied 158 constitutions, which helped in understanding the Political Systems, through normative, Empirical and Scientific Approaches later.
Contribution of traditional Method of studying comparative Politics through legal institutional Approaches of A.V Dicey, K.C Wheare helped in modernisation in developing countries (Eg) India adopted Parliamentary system from UK and Judicial Independence from USA, but at the same time were parochial, Eurocentric in nature and also responsible for Underdeveloped State [Neo Marxist idea of Hamza Alavi).
later, Structuralism of David Easton based on sociologic + Talcott Parson's approach helped in understanding Political system through input outputs Mechanism, but came to be criticized as Again Chain theory' and [??] change by Marxists.
Then, Gabriel Almond and Powell through structural functional approach (inspired from Anthropologist like Malinowski) ruled that different political system are at different stages of development and compared political Parties, Pressure Groups among developed and developing countries.
Hence later Political Development approach by Lucian Pye and Political Modernisation approach by Samuel P. Huntington helped in understanding the concept of Political Decay is going on in some countries, due to mismatch between Political awareness and Constitutionalisation of Institutions.
Also late came Gabriel Almond and Sydney Verba's book Civic Culture which called for 'Popular sovereignty' similar to Rousseau's General will theory mix of Parochial, Subject and Active civic culture, which helped in avoid [?] and social into anomie between Developed and Developing world # Huntington's notion, # metoo, # Fukuyama notion.
Challenges to comparative Politics in the Context of Globalization -> arise from the fact that Globalization is defined as Global Village (Kenichi Ohmae) as Borderless world by Marshall McLuhan where our interaction have more faster, further, deeper and faster [Thomas Friedman].
While on one hand, Comparative political study has become easy because of easy access of functioning of political system through Interconnectedness like what is said by Conservatives that Sovereignty is not compromised, and it has led to concept of Pooled Sovereignty (eg) European Union.
But on the other hand, it has given rise to Problems without Passports (Kofi Annan) like Non-State Actors led Terrorism, and Influence of Big Tech (eg) the recent Cyberoutage by Microsoft Security Update shows the danger of Interconnectedness.
Hence, Comparative Politics is an evolving field where the only direction is to go forward through learnings.