Topper Copies

Evaluate the Marxist assertion that international politics is driven by the interests of the capitalist class rather than the interests of states. How does this view challenge the fundamental assumptions of Realist and Liberal theories?

Damanpreet Arora, AIR 103, 2024

Marxist were not against the Internationalisation of politics' but were against the model in which they held that International Politics is nothing but the continuation of capitalism on Global scale. Lenin even called the first world war as the Capitalist war.

Karl Marx also realised that Search of profit will force capitalist to settle everywhere and move anywhere this was more explained by the Instrumental theory / Dependency theory propounded by Immanuel Wallerstein who held that it is capitalist class that matter as not interest of states through the concept of core, periphery and semi periphery.

Similarly, Gramscian scholars Robert Cox explained how Ideological fact play dominant role behind material power like USA's free trade. Idea helped it gave the idea of becoming Super Power.

It challenges the basic assumptions of both Realism and Marxism, because while Realists believe that Balance of Power is required to overcome security Dilemma (2) Morgenthau and Mearsheimer called for maximisation of power, but Marxism has criticized such notion as state increasing Powers to increase its domination on the world and continue to exploitation its interests (3) Through Arms sales, Providing conditional loans (4) China's Chequebook diplomacy and hence bears (its) [?] tactic of maximising its domination).

Similarly, Marxists sees liberal institutionalism of Woodrow Wilson and Joseph Nye as a Bourgeoisie-committee, which not Just convert Jungle into Zoo, but in turn deprives the Jungle of the Resources through tactic of 'Gunboat Diplomacy' which marxist call as hyper-fortified transaction diplomacies.

Hence, looking at above arguments International Politics is what is best described as place of cooperation where scholars like Shashi Tharoor credits for the prevention of a nuclear and third world, but are currently under crisis for their failure to solve Russia Ukraine, Israel Palestine conflicts