How is Comprehensive National Power an advanced concept?
Damanpreet Arora, AIR 103, 2024
In Political Science, 'Power' is an aristotelian concept, and Robert Dahl (Elitist) calls it as 'Relational', however the sense of Powers are two levels (Actor Model) which are categorized as high power (USA), middle power (India).
But, the concept of Comprehensive National Power is an advanced concept which combines Hard Power, Soft power of Joseph Nye, Smart power and also the power which has capability to manage all of these as Comprehensive National Power (Internal + External Balancing) based on Idea of Sovereignty.
It is also an advanced concept because where the traditionalists like Robert Michels, Pareto, Raymond Aron calls the Oligarchy as the Iron laws, & liberals like Robert Dahl mentions about Polyarchy, but how the state not only increase its capacity to manage Internal conflicts (Concept of Insecurity Dilemma by 3rd world Realist like Mohammad Ayoob), but is also the perfect balance between the 'Security Maximise' of Defensive Realism and (Power Maximise of Offensive Realism).
Here, it is an advanced concept, but we can see the pitfalls of accumulation of Power when it is preponderant in the case of Napolean of France ad Kaiser Wilhelm of Germany, thus a balance is necessary to remain in the Real Politics.