Discuss the main arguments of Dependency Theory as a critique of Liberal Modernization Theory.
Damanpreet Arora, AIR 103, 2024
'Dependency Theory' and the whole-concept of 'Dependence' is a Marxist Discourse where 'core', Periphery and 'semi-periphery' and notion of colonial states has been argued by Instrumentalist and Marxist Scholars, Immanuel-Wallerstein.
In critique to Liberal Modernization theory in which it was argued that Political Eco development (Lucian Pye) leads to Political Development- Modernization (Samuel P. Huntington) based on the parameters of Rationalisation, Urbanization, Industrialisation where Liberal and Rights are given more value as opposed to Suppression.
However, Dependency theory argues that 'Capitalism' is still the reality
[a concentric-circle diagram: "Periphery" on the outer ring, "core" at the centre, "semi periphery" on an inner ring, with an arrow from an inner ring toward "semi periphery"]
where exploitation is continuing is the notion of underdeveloping Kwame Nkrumah
he fears neo colonialism which can be stated (China Model (eg) 99 year lease of hambantota port and current status in Cambodia), and MNCs led model [Non State Actor] where Peripheries became the supplier of raw materials and leads to its underdevelopment.
Here, Dependency theory bursts the idea of liberal Modernization by calling it capitalism on Global Scale, this was also held by Robert-Gilpin in his 'Foundation for Imperial Age' Book where he called 'Rule of Bourgeoisie' as the Ultimate reality.