The Governor's role in Indian states has often been a contentious issue. Discuss in the context of recent political developments in Indian states.
Vishwajeet Gupta, AIR 67, 2025
Governor serves as the dual role of agent of the Union as well as head of government at state level, working on aid and advice of State Council of Ministers.
Recent instances have shone light on the contentious nature of this relationship as frictions keep coming out. Governor's powers to appoint Vice-Chancellors of State Universities has been the bone of contention in Kerala. Independent foray into executive domain has raised questions in Bengal. And the recent Supreme Court judgement highlighted the issue of non-passage of Bills in Tamil Nadu.
The Supreme Court has framed a timeline for the governor to grant assent to State legislations or to reserve the bill for Parliament.
| Assent/Reserve | Timeline | |---|---| | Assent with aid & advice of CoM | 1 month | | Assent without aid/advice of CoM | 3 months | | Reservation for President's approval | 1 month |
Moreover, discretionary powers of the Governor to appoint Chief Minister got highlighted during early morning swearing-in of Maharashtra CM. Supreme Court has also stressed on the floor test in Assembly as the marker of majority in Nabam Rebia v. Deputy Speaker Case (2016).
There have also been tussles over Governor's speech in State Assembly, where TN Governor did not stick to the given script and diverted from the text.
Furthermore, the incessant and irregular transfers of Governors is a Union prerogative that aids the federal structure.
Non-consultation of State government, Chief Minister and political appointees as Governors have also been highlighted by the emerging tussles.
These contentious issues have reframed and disturbed the federal fabric of the Indian polity that needs to be addressed.
Sarkaria Commission proposed for non-political appointment of Governors in states with consultation of Chief Minister.
Punchhi Commission (2007) has proposed/advocated a secure tenure of Governor which should not be disturbed unless for extra-ordinary circumstances. There is also a need to reform and appoint Governors from non-political backgrounds.
Thus, Governor as an institution has gone through several churns of political tussles and needs to be reimagined as an impartial office working to balance the harmony between state legislative promises and public governance framework.