For Machiavelli, religion is a tool for political stability. Discuss this utilitarian view of religion and its implications for secular governance.
Vishwajeet Gupta, AIR 67, 2025
Religion was always an instrumental 'tool' for Machiavelli to secure obedience and order from the citizenry, rather than an intrinsic value.
Machiavelli advises in his book 'The Prince' that religions is the binding factor that wields enormous power over people. It can be skillfully manipulated to demand subservience for ensuring political stability.
This divorce between state and religion has given the negative connotations to Machiavellian thought. However, he argues that political morality is not personal morality.
Politics is different from ethics and hence, they should not be judged on similar standards. Religion can and should be another tool in the arsenal of the King to demand respect.
Such utilitarian view of religion has severe implications on secular governance framework. A utilitarian approach to religion disempowers the personal morality and guides political decision-making based on brute objectivity. Further, cultural sensitivities are often ignored due to strict implementation of secular decisions. The values of religious ideals are neglected and could sow further discontent among populace dealt with heavy-handedness.
Secular governance framework gets a boost due to non-religiously bound policies as the arena of judicious and contemporarily relevant decisions is widened. Eg., Saudi Arabia's decisions to allow women drivers and Ataturk viewpoint.
But certain aspects of secular governance takes a hit due to negligence towards religiously driven way of life. Eg., Parsi households denying women entry in fire temples. Similar viewpoint was highlighted by Justice Indu Malhotra in Sabarimala judgement (2018).
Thus, religion plays an instrumental role in governance design of a nation and Machiavellian approach should be applied with caution.