Do participatory and deliberative democracies offer viable alternatives or necessary complements to liberal constitutional democracy? Comment.
Vishwajeet Gupta, AIR 67, 2025
Democracy as a discourse has gained much attention through liberal institutional order, however the roots of the concept can be traced back to ancient Greek and Indian traditions [Chola empire].
Participatory and deliberative democracies are the manifestations of people participating in decision making. Participatory democracy model emphasizes on procedural involvement in the policy inputs through voting, referendums, etc.
Deliberative democracy however is the enhanced role of individuals by providing active policy inputs through deliberations.
Deliberative democracy highlights the essence of a democratic process as visible in ancient Indian institutions of Sabhas and Samitis. Modern constitutional democracies aimed to provide the similar interactions through 73rd and 74th Amendments, 1992 [Gram Sabhas].
These models of democracy might act as the alternatives of liberal constitutional democracy but this assumption is highly doubted by Elitist theories of Robert Dahl and Charles Lindblom.
The Rousseau's concept of deliberative democracy has not been a massive success due to lack of technical expertise and availability of time and resources.
However, the realisation of these models as effective instrument of power decentralization has prompted countries worldwide to develop local participatory institutions like Hong Kong's Social Relations Unit (SRU).
Deliberative democracy is also being manifested through local institutions as District Planning Committees (DPC), local Area Units (LAU), Consultative forums and legislative initiatives like PESA Act 1996 to establish Autonomous District Councils (ADC).
Thus, these democratic approaches have aided and complemented the deepening of liberal constitutional democracy around the world. Yogendra Yadav has called it a "democratic upsurge" due to upliftment of hitherto ignored classes and castes into mainstream politics.
Recent challenges to such an attempt at complementarity have been lack of power devolution, functional inadequacy and fund crunch. Moreover, segregated silos of policy making affect broader developmental plans.
Nonetheless, the liberal constitutionalism has been strengthened by the inculcation of participatory and deliberative democracies in the field of human empowerment paradigm.