How did the behavioural and post-behavioural approaches together contribute to methodological pluralism in political science?
Vishwajeet Gupta, AIR 67, 2025
Behavioural and post-behavioural approaches to political science emerged as a response to decline in the discipline, first due to traditional approaches and secondly later due to insufficiency in explaining social movements.
Guided by David Easton's approach to quantify and standardise the discipline, behavioural approaches such as Systems approach, Structural-functional approach, etc. emerged. These approaches built on the framework of David Easton but evolved the understanding through complex interplay of interacting elements.
Systems approach defined the criteria of input and output in a fixed environment, while the response funneled through a feedback loop.
Structural-functional approach took the approaches earlier employed a step further and codified interest aggregation as well as articulation through structural factors. Herein, the 'output' was systematised as rule making, implementation & adjudication.
Due to inefficiency of these approaches to explain evolving paradigms in USA and Western countries, there emerged 'Credo of Relevance' by David Easton to further enrich the methodology by inculcating theory, data and value together.
On these lines, new approaches as Political Development approach, Political Economy approach, etc. emerged which took the methodological pluralism to its peak.
Political Development approach defined the growth of democracy as the metric of development while Political economy emphasized on the economic growth as the prime metric.
These approaches have turn and again explained the functioning of democracies and nation-states in a complex set of constant internal and external environment changes due to structural differences.
Critics, however, pointed out the status-quoist nature of these theories and approaches that keep the western liberal democracy as the ideal for all the countries.
The emergent third world countries in Asia and Africa have their own set of challenges and structures [Prismatic Societies] that may not align with these approaches.
Nonetheless, these approaches have helped build the relevance of Political Science as a discipline despite multiple declines.
These approaches further reflect the encompassing and evolving nature of the discipline to explain contemporary events aptly.