Topper Copies

Why did Monetarists assume that fiscal policy is fully ineffective?

Ruhani, AIR 5, 2023

Monetarists like Milton Friedman believed that only money matters and fiscal policy is ineffective (FP) because of the following reasons:

1. Time lags: FP suffers from significant time lags, meaning there is a delay between implementation of FP and its impact on the economy. - They believe that by the time FP takes effect, economy may have already adjusted, rendering FP ineffective. 2. Crowding out: Monetarists believe that increased government expenditure crowds out private investment, thus, there is no increase in A.D. (aggregate demand) and thus, FP is ineffective. 3. Rational expectations: Monetarists assume that in the long-run, individuals and businesses correctly anticipate the fiscal policy of govt and accordingly adjust their behaviour, minimizing impact of discretionary FP. 4. High interest sensitivity of investment: Monetarists assume that the investment demand is highly sensitive to the interest rate. As a result, the IS curve is relatively flat - Thus, due to this, any expansionary FP does not lead to substantial increase in output.

[a rate of interest vs output diagram with a steep LM curve and two flat IS curves, IS(G₀) and IS'(G₁), shifted right with Y₀ and Y₁ marked]

Monetarists argue that LM is steep, so FP has little impact.

[a rate of interest vs output diagram with a steep LM curve and two flat IS curves, IS and IS', close together with Y₀ and Y₁ marked]

Due to the above reasons, monetarists assume that fiscal policy is fully ineffective.