"Right is prior to good". Critically examine. (15 Marks)
Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025
Locke is the father of Liberalism. Liberalism however is a meta-ideology that has constantly evolved from classical to modern to neoliberal but with liberty as central theme.
The slogan 'right is prior to good' is of classical liberals like Locke. They believed that humans are rational & so require autonomy of individual self, capable of decision making & need freedom/liberty from society & state.
Locke argues that since man is rational has natural rights in state of nature, thus state should be nightwatchman, or minimal state. The state thus will have to respect right of all individuals.
This is because right is prior to good. Right of all individuals are prior to the total good of society. Good is defined as 'greatest happiness of greatest number' by utilitarians as Bentham.
Bentham believes good is prior to rights. And thus rights of few can be sacrificed for good. It is majoritarian & hence against Kant's categorical imperative.
Locke is of natural right tradition & for him right of no one should be compromised for greater good. He gives equality- legal, moral and of opportunity, making rights prior to good.
This view stems from Locke's aggregative and artificial view of society. Since, society & state are artificial & man is creator, man & his rights should be prioritised. He proposed 'necessary evil' 'police state'.
Modern liberals talk of giving not formal equality but substantive equality by establishing welfare state & bring concept of positive liberty.
'Right is prior to good' is revived under Nozick's 'entitlement theory of Justice'. In 'anarchy, state & utopia', he calls welfare state as immoral, against personality of man & demands absolute right to property that is legally acquired (historical view).
Today's welfare states are established on following rights of all- on Kant's categorical imperative but 'good' (progressive taxation) is prior to right.