"One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman." (Simone de Beauvoir). Comment. (15 Marks)
Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025
Virginia Woolf defines feminism as the belief that women should get rights & opportunities similar to men. This thought is of 1st wave of liberal feminism (Mary Wollstonecraft).
This was followed by 2nd wave of Radical feminism by Betty Friedan in 'Mystique feminism'. Radical feminists differentiate between sex and gender, calling out to end the patriarchal basic structure of society (Shiela S.F.)
Simone De Beauvoir, a radical feminist, in her book 'the second sex' says that 'one is not born but becomes a woman'. She argues that the sex of someone is biological, however gender is social. The 'essentialism' prevalent in patriarchal societies gives an "essence" to child as soon as it is born depending on biological features.
Essentialism argues for certain essential features of a woman. A female child of birth, is not allowed to choose own 'existence' but given essence. She has to live according to society's essence of what is right for a woman, & regularly conform to societal norms. One is thus not born woman but becomes a woman by accommodating to society's essentialism.
Simone also says that the identity of woman is provisional, done with respect to men, she has no independent existence in patriarchal society. She is not second but secondary sex.
Radical feminists show how patriarchy is perpetuated by myths, violence and even knowledge such as Sigmund Freud's psychoanalysis - similar to Foucault's knowledge power connection.
They call for ending the patriarchy structure. demand of 'personal is political' by Carole Hanisch is central to radical feminism. They demand state's intervention in private sphere.
While some suggestions of Radical feminism as ending family were radical, state intervention has seen women empowerment such as Sabrimala judgment & triple talaq judgment by Supreme Court of India.