Freedom is both the primary end and the principal means of development. In context of the given statement, discuss how Amartya Sen makes a philosophical case that freedom-centered development can create a better society and economy? (20 Marks)
Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025
Freedom & liberty is the central value of dominant ideology of liberalism and western society. The concept of liberty has however changed from positive & negative liberty.
The change centered to the historic debate between liberty & equality. This debate was taken up by Rawls in his theory of Justice (1971) who integrates liberty & equality.
Rawlsian notion of justice gives liberty and accommodates equality - creating a welfare state. Under welfare state, the focus is on positive liberty, trend started by modern liberals (T H Green).
Rawlsian theory however lacks as it distributes primary goods but does not make initial distribution fair.
For Sen, the initial distribution needs to be fair for equality is substantive terms, and substantive freedom. The purpose of theory of sen is to bring down deprivations of society.
Sen argues that no amount of goods' distribution (Rawls) or compensation for brute luck (Dworkin) will make distribution fair. This cannot be done till their is equality of Capability.
Capability for sen, is ability to do something that gives a sense of well-being. When this ability is missing, such as to read, write no amount of resources/goods such as books, tables can achieve equality or freedom.
Sen defines freedom or liberty as positive liberty. It is the freedom that increases under state as state focuses on "capacity development". This freedom will give man capacity to "utilise" resources & goods - to development and reducing deprivations as poverty. This is what he defines freedom-centred development.
This development will allow freedom (positive liberty or capacity) as a means to achieve the primary end of freedom. True Liberty from deprivation and opportunities to utilise Rawls' 'equal maximum liberty', will come after capacity development.
Amartya Sen's theory led to change of definition of term development - from not just economic growth, but to also include capacity development - (eg-health, education) by UNDP in HDI index (started in 1990).
Social liberals like Sen thus argue that India to reap benefits of globalisation & achieve demographic dividend must invest in education, health, i.e: capacity building of individual. This is similar to 3rd way or 'Clintonomics' after Neo-liberalism & its inequalities (Thomas Piketty).