Compare Austin's theory of Sovereignty with that of Pluralists (10 Marks)
Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025
The concept of sovereignty differentiates modern nation states from medieval political system. Hobbes is known as first modern thinker as gave theory of sovereignty.
Hobbes theory & Austinian theory are similar - as propose monistic theory of sovereignty. For Austin, state is absolute, it is the only source of law (positive law). Austin gives sovereignty to state which is absolute, inseparable & non-transferable. This is seen in Hobbes' Leviathan.
Pluralists like Laski criticise the monistic theory of sovereignty for promoting states as Nazi Germany, wars and human right violations. They thus propose division of sovereignty.
Philosophical explanation is provided by Laski who argues that since man is multi-dimensional, society is federal, authority should also be federal.
Thus, State's sovereignty should be divided among various associations & hence political obligation too. 'State is one of many associations' for Pluralists. Macher even argues that political obligation should only be to 'service state'.
This concept of Pluralists is closer to medieval Europe. This has however been the inspiration before formation of regional (EU) & international multilateral forums (as UN).