Topper Copies

Write a short note on 'Overlapping Consensus'. (10 Marks)

Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025

Rawls gave liberal theory of justice in 1971 with his book 'Theory of Justice'. His theory gave principles of distribution of primary goods in "lexical order" after reflective equilibrium by Kantian men.

Since the principles were given by 'procedural theory' where individuals were in their original position under veil of ignorance, Rawls argued for their universality.

Communitarianism criticise the universalistic aspect of Rawlsian theory. Michael Walzer argues that man can never be completely rational, in original position and thus "right is not prior to good but determined by good."

Communitarian critique was based on their view that man is not "atomistic" or if "unencumbered" but embedded self. Thus, until there is "overarching consensus" on way of lyf, there can never be universalalistic principles of justice.

Rawls in his 'Political Liberalism' revised his views & agreed that his principles are for developed western societies that are democratic. For him, even people with different backgrounds will have not only "overarching" but "overlapping consensus" on principles of justice - if not all atleast in the political sphere. Thus, in democratic west all will agree to one view of "political justice".

Rawls is criticised by Nozick in his entitlement theory of justice, for being masculinist by feminists as Carole Pateman. Even A. Sen disagrees & questions Rawls' intent to come up with universalist theory.

However, Rawls enriched the idea - architectonic idea of justice - a tradition that started with Plato.