Topper Copies

The Ambedkar-Gandhi debate although has a special place in the academic discourse has become a redundant debate. Discuss (15 Marks)

Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025

Ambedkar and Gandhi are the greatest political thinkers of modern India. Bhikhu Parekh criticizes Indian thought on view that different views on various aspects had not allowed 'Political theorisation' by Indians for universal theory.

Ambedkar & Gandhi debate has various facets. They differ on course action and priorities. While Gandhi has truth & non violence based satyagraha as his political weapon, Ambedkar calls it "grammar of anarchy" - especially in independent India.

Ambedkar coined the term 'Dalit' against Gandhi's 'harijan' arguing for it creating false consciousness. Ambedkar believed that transfer of power without 'social revolution' & annihilation of caste would be no 'Swaraj'. He criticised Gandhi for justifying caste as varna system for division of labours, & prioritising political freedom over social revolution.

The debate intensifies with Gandhi's focus on freedom struggle and Ambedkar on "social justice" for downtrodden depressed classes.

The debate however now has become a redundant debate. It is as today India has got political freedom, political swaraj. India today still has 'social swaraj' of Gandhi & Ambedkar's vision of dalit emancipation ongoing, under our transformative constitution.

The goal now doesn't need debate of priority as social revolution was chosen as one of aims of independent India.

The debate of method of peaceful satyagraha is widely settled with various Gandhian protests around India.

Both focused on education, morality, continuity of ethics & virtues, end of untouchability (Article 17) - all of which are base of our constitution and political policy today - seen in Part III and part IV of constitution.