Discuss Kaldor Hicks Principle of distribution. How was it resolved by Scitovsky's paradox.
Ruhani, AIR 5, 2023
Kaldor Hicks Principle of distribution states that when a policy change makes some people better off and some other people worse off, then winners can compensate the losers to obtain a fair distribution.
[a utility possibility frontier diagram, U_B against U_A, with point P inside the frontier and points R and T on it, and point Q above and to the left of R]
- A policy change which involves movement from P to T (in figure) increases utility of B but decreases utility of A. - Kaldor-Hicks state that in such case, redistribution should occur in such a way that we move from point T to point Q. - At Q, A's utility is same as before (as at point P) and B's utility is still higher than at P. - Thus, this principle can be used for a fair distribution of resources
Inconsistency problem in Kaldor-Hicks (as pointed out by Scitovsky)
[a diagram of two utility possibility frontiers, an outer curve JJ' and an inner curve GG', with points P and R on JJ' and Q on GG', and S between R and JJ'; labelled "Fig 2: Policy change"]
- If a policy change involves movement from point P (on JJ' curve) to point Q (on GG' curve), then in P → Q, U_A increases but U_B decreases. - Thus, redistribution can occur in such a way that we move from Q to R. - At R, U_A increases and U_B remains same as before (as at point P) - Thus, Q > P — (1) (Q is a better allocation than P).
Reverse policy change (from Q to P): Then in Q → P, U_B increases but U_A decreases. - Thus, redistribution can occur to point S. - At point S, U_B increases but U_A remains same as at point Q. - Thus, P > Q — (2)
Thus, (1) and (2) contradict each other. - This is called Scitovsky Paradox.
Scitovsky stated that the reversal test will be satisfied if a policy change involves movement from a Utility Possibility Frontier (UPF) to another point on a parallel UPF. This will satisfy Scitovsky's Double Criteria.
[a diagram of two concentric quarter-circle utility possibility frontiers, points P and S on the inner curve, Q and R on the outer curve, with Q connected down to R]
- If policy change involves movement from P to Q, then redistribution can occur to point R. - If policy is reversed and there is movement from Q to P, then no redistribution can occur. - Thus, Q > P but P > Q is not true. - Thus, parallel UPF's satisfy Scitovsky's Double Criteria and help to resolve the Scitovsky paradox.