"Aristotle differs from his master Plato, much more in the form and method than in the substance of his thought"(Dunning). Critically examine. (20 Marks)
Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025
Aristotle and Plato belong to Socratic tradition of ancient Greece. While Aristotle was a disciple of Plato, he was also the biggest critic of Plato.
Aristotle & Plato differ in form and method of their political theories, as Dunning points out. Plato is an idealist for whom 'reality is the shadow of idea'. his epistemology thus is 'reason' & method of dialectics.
For Plato, only idea is real, and matter is illusion. It is because true knowledge is possible only for permanent world & this is world of change. Plato believes in 'dualism' & that idea is transcendental & universal, can exist without matter.
Aristotle is a physician and empiricist. he believes that idea is real but even matter is real (golden mean-theory of matter). This world is changing but, we can study it as change is "teleological", where potentiality converting to actuality.
Since, matter is real, his method (epistemology) is empirical. Aristotle observes the change rather than search for it in his soul (reason in soul) like Plato.
Aristotle thus calls that king/ruler should be not only wise in the world of ideas but also worldly wise. Thus, they differ in form (matter real for Aristotle & idea for Plato) & method (rational or empirical for Aristotle).
However, Plato & Aristotle are similar in substance of their political thought. Both believe in Socratic tradition of idealism where man is a social or political animal. Man is part of state & state is prior to individual. For both, there is continuity in ethics & politics.
however, Dunning is wrong to propose that substance of both thoughts is similar in all ways. While Plato is radical & extremist, seen in his theory of philosopher king (even Queens) who he gives absolute power. But, he puts guardian class under communism, of property & family.
Aristotle criticises the best ideal state of philosophers king/monarchy as it is difficult to find such king & also as power corrupts. He argues that "law is reason without passion" & thus proposes 'Polity' as best ideal state.
While both doubt the individual intellectual capacity (Plato's myth of metal), Aristotle believes 'collective decision' can be wiser than by an individual. For him, 'authority of statesman is different from master.'
Aristotle is conservative & status quoist-person in theory of citizenship and theory of property (against Plato's communism) he gives theory of revolution & believes justice is treating equals equally & unequals unequally.
Aristotle & Plato thues differ widely in their thoughts but are child of their times. As Whitehead mentions 'western political thought is nothing but footnotes of Plato & Aristotle', shows their importance.