Human rights are those political parameters which act as a guide for governments and institutions as to how to treat people. Critically examine the given statement. (15 Marks)
Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025
Human rights' concept was envisaged after world war 2 in form of 'Universal declaration of human rights' (UDHR) in 1948.
These rights are universal, based on equality so available to all humans irrespective of caste, creed, race, etc & across all nations.
These rights in recent times have become the political parameters that guide the governments on what rights can be guaranteed in their nations & given status of fundamental rights (Part III in India). these guide on how nations should treat their people. This is because it is derived from theory of natural right of Locke and categorical imperative by Kant, which argue that rights are nature given & thus must be protected by state. Kant argues that 'human-dignity' is imperative for all humans.
However, many nations argue for 'culture relative' rights. Nations such as China, SE Asia (eg- Mahathir Mohammad) argue that human rights are not Asian values, & refuse to incorporate human rights as guidance to treat people.
Culture relativists argue that rights to people should be given according to culture they are part of, as human is embedded self. Asian values of collectivism, guided democracy, focus on society are different from western nations of individualism, liberty, importance to man over society. Thus, different values & culture demand different rights. Recently, Taliban banned education of girls beyond 6th - reasoning that it is Shariah law based.
These nations thus call human rights as propaganda by west for seeking change and cultural imperialism. This has led to human right violations eg. uighur muslims, China.
Amartya Sen criticises "Asian values" as propaganda to condone authoritarianism human rights are integral to humans & thus some basic rights must be given to all irrespective of culture" too