Topper Copies

How does the debate around the Rawlsian notion of justice have made justice a pluralistic concept? (20 Marks)

Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025

Justice is the architectural concept of political science. Rawls gave his theory of 'Justice' in 1971 referencing the dominant theory of utilitarianism's greatest happiness of greatest number' in liberalism.

Rawlsian notion of justice is derived by social contract (Lockean tradition) between Kantian men. It is a procedural theory to determine distribution of primary goods in society based on inviolability of human dignity.

Rawls gives his 3 principles of justice in lexical order - decided by people in their original position and under veil of ignorance. These are -

1. All should get maximum possible liberty. The inequality is justified if - 2. Equality of opportunity to all 3. results into maximum advantage for least advantaged. (Difference principle)

Rawls argues that since Kantian men were under veil of ignorance and in original position, they are rational. Principles of justice are thus universal.

The debate on Rawlsian notion starts as communitarians like Michael Walzer & Sandel criticise Rawls. They argue that man is not unencumbered self (atomistic) but 'embedded self', part of community.

Thus, man is never rational, his choices a product of his community. Also, man can never be in the original position & thus no universal theory of justice. Sandel argues 'different good' ought to be distributed differently according to different principles'. They voted for pluralistic theory than monistic, universal theory of justice.

Rawls changed his theory in 'Political liberalism' & argued that principles will be valid in democratic societies where people will build 'overlapping consensus' on principles in political sphere.

Rawls' concept was also debated by Feminists Carole Pateman called his theory as masculinist & Carole Gilligan called for including ethics of care. They rejected a monistic theory where injustice of women is not dealt. Marion Iris Young later argues for 'differentiated citizenship' - pluralistic justice.

Rawls' theory and his universalist application is critiqued by Amartya Sen, who argues for a functional theory. Sen gives justice as equality of capability, whereas Dworkin gives resource egalitarianism -> to make initial distribution fair.

Thus, debates around Rawls' along with 'neo liberal entitlement theory' by Nozick argued that equality & liberty are non compatible as given by Rawls.

These debates reflected how universal theory of justice - a monistic theory is still not achieved. We can only have pluralistic theory of justice - that differs according to various societies, sections (example women - give multicultural rights) and various sectors (political, economical) etc.

However, Rawls' theory revived political philosophy, established post-behaviouralism & so called Father of Political science in contemporary times.